Bhagavad-gita chapter 17: The three kinds of faith (Shraddhatraya-vibhaga-yoga), Arnold's translation
About this chapter
Arjuna asks about people who worship with faith but without following scripture. Krishna answers that faith itself takes the colour of the three qualities described in chapter 14, and that a person is what their faith is. He then applies the threefold scheme to daily life: foods that are wholesome, foods that are too bitter, sour or hot, and foods that are stale; sacrifices made from duty, for show, or without rule; austerities of body, speech and mind; and gifts given at the right time to a worthy person, given for return, or given with contempt.
Arnold ends the chapter at the description of gifts. He leaves out the final verses, on the sacred formula om tat sat (17.23–28 in the usual numbering), which he considered of doubtful authenticity.
Sanskrit title: Shraddhatraya-vibhaga-yoga · Verses: 28 in the usual numbering · Arnold's title: Religion by the Threefold Faith · Introduction: written by Bhakti Atlas
The text, in Edwin Arnold's translation (1885)
Arjuna
If men forsake the holy ordinance,
Heedless of Shastras, yet keep faith at heart
And worship, what shall be the state of those,
Great Krishna! Sattwan, Rajas, Tamas? Say!
Krishna
Threefold the faith is of mankind and springs
From those three qualities,—becoming "true,"
Or "passion-stained," or "dark," as thou shalt hear!
The faith of each believer, Indian Prince!
Conforms itself to what he truly is.
Where thou shalt see a worshipper, that one
To what he worships lives assimilate,
[Such as the shrine, so is the votary,]
The "soothfast" souls adore true gods; the souls
Obeying Rajas worship Rakshasas1
Or Yakshas; and the men of Darkness pray
To Pretas and to Bhutas.2 Yea, and those
Who practise bitter penance, not enjoined
By rightful rule—penance which hath its root
In self-sufficient, proud hypocrisies—
Those men, passion-beset, violent, wild,
Torturing—the witless ones—My elements
Shut in fair company within their flesh,
(Nay, Me myself, present within the flesh!)
Know them to devils devoted, not to Heaven!
For like as foods are threefold for mankind
In nourishing, so is there threefold way
Of worship, abstinence, and almsgiving!
Hear this of Me! there is a food which brings
Force, substance, strength, and health, and joy to live,
Being well-seasoned, cordial, comforting,
The "Soothfast" meat. And there be foods which bring
Aches and unrests, and burning blood, and grief,
Being too biting, heating, salt, and sharp,
And therefore craved by too strong appetite.
And there is foul food—kept from over-night,3
Savourless, filthy, which the foul will eat,
A feast of rottenness, meet for the lips
Of such as love the "Darkness."
Thus with rites;—
A sacrifice not for rewardment made,
Offered in rightful wise, when he who vows
Sayeth, with heart devout, "This I should do!"
Is "Soothfast" rite. But sacrifice for gain,
Offered for good repute, be sure that this,
O Best of Bharatas! is Rajas-rite,
With stamp of "passion." And a sacrifice
Offered against the laws, with no due dole
Of food-giving, with no accompaniment
Of hallowed hymn, nor largesse to the priests,
In faithless celebration, call it vile,
The deed of "Darkness!"—lost!
Worship of gods
Meriting worship; lowly reverence
Of Twice-borns, Teachers, Elders; Purity,
Rectitude, and the Brahmacharya's vow,
And not to injure any helpless thing,—
These make a true religiousness of Act.
Words causing no man woe, words ever true,
Gentle and pleasing words, and those ye say
In murmured reading of a Sacred Writ,—
These make the true religiousness of Speech.
Serenity of soul, benignity,
Sway of the silent Spirit, constant stress
To sanctify the Nature,—these things make
Good rite, and true religiousness of Mind.
Such threefold faith, in highest piety
Kept, with no hope of gain, by hearts devote,
Is perfect work of Sattwan, true belief.
Religion shown in act of proud display
To win good entertainment, worship, fame,
Such—say I—is of Rajas, rash and vain.
Religion followed by a witless will
To torture self, or come at power to hurt
Another,—'tis of Tamas, dark and ill.
The gift lovingly given, when one shall say
"Now must I gladly give!" when he who takes
Can render nothing back; made in due place,
Due time, and to a meet recipient,
Is gift of Sattwan, fair and profitable.
The gift selfishly given, where to receive
Is hoped again, or when some end is sought,
Or where the gift is proffered with a grudge,
This is of Rajas, stained with impulse, ill.
The gift churlishly flung, at evil time,
In wrongful place, to base recipient,
Made in disdain or harsh unkindliness,
Is gift of Tamas, dark; it doth not bless!4
HERE ENDETH CHAPTER XVII. OF THE BHAGAVAD-GITA,
Entitled "Sraddhatrayavibhagayog,"
Or "The Book of Religion by the Threefold Kinds of Faith."
Arnold's notes
- Rakshasas and Yakshas are unembodied but capricious beings of great power, gifts, and beauty, same times also of benignity. ↩
- These are spirits of evil wandering ghosts. ↩
- Yatayaman, food which has remained after the watches of the night. In India this would probably "go bad." ↩
- I omit the concluding shlokas, as of very doubtful authenticity. ↩
All 18 chapters
- 1. Arjuna-vishada-yoga (Arjuna's despair)
- 2. Sankhya-yoga (the yoga of understanding)
- 3. Karma-yoga (the yoga of action)
- 4. Jnana-karma-sannyasa-yoga (knowledge and the renunciation of action)
- 5. Karma-sannyasa-yoga (renouncing action)
- 6. Dhyana-yoga (the yoga of meditation)
- 7. Jnana-vijnana-yoga (knowledge and realisation)
- 8. Akshara-brahma-yoga (the imperishable absolute)
- 9. Raja-vidya-raja-guhya-yoga (the royal knowledge and the royal secret)
- 10. Vibhuti-yoga (the divine manifestations)
- 11. Vishvarupa-darshana-yoga (the vision of the universal form)
- 12. Bhakti-yoga (the yoga of devotion)
- 13. Kshetra-kshetrajna-vibhaga-yoga (the field and the knower of the field)
- 14. Gunatraya-vibhaga-yoga (the three qualities of nature)
- 15. Purushottama-yoga (the supreme person)
- 16. Daivasura-sampad-vibhaga-yoga (the divine and demonic natures)
- 17. Shraddhatraya-vibhaga-yoga (the three kinds of faith)
- 18. Moksha-sannyasa-yoga (liberation through renunciation)
Method, sources and licence
The translation is Edwin Arnold's The Song Celestial, or Bhagavad-Gita (from the Mahabharata), first published in London by Trübner & Co. in 1885. Arnold died in 1904 and the translation is in the public domain. Our text follows the digitised edition prepared by J. C. Byers from a 1900 New York printing (Truslove, Hanson & Comba), released as eBook #2388 by Project Gutenberg; we downloaded it on 2026-11-13. We changed only the presentation: double hyphens are printed as dashes, two lines broken by the transcription are rejoined, and the translator's footnotes are numbered by chapter. Spelling, punctuation and Arnold's omissions are kept as published.
Arnold wrote in verse and did not number the verses, so his lines cannot be matched one for one with the Sanskrit; the verse references in our introduction follow the standard Sanskrit numbering. The introduction and the chapter information are original texts by Bhakti Atlas. This page is not a Project Gutenberg edition.